Card shop in Cincinnati, OH
Highball Cincy
Hours
| Mon | Closed |
|---|---|
| Tue | Closed |
| Wed | 16:00–22:00 |
| Thu | 16:00–01:00 |
| Fri | 15:00–01:00 |
| Sat | 13:00–01:00 |
| Sun | 13:00–18:00 |
What to expect at Highball Cincy
Highball Cincy has built one of the stronger reputations on its block — 4.7★ across 117 Google reviews is the kind of number that only emerges from years of consistent service. Players return, bring friends, and leave reviews that mention staff by name.
Games at this shop
Below are the trading card games we've identified as supported at this shop, each with context about how that game plays and what to look for when you visit.
We haven't yet verified the specific trading card games stocked at Highball Cincy. Most general-purpose game and hobby shops in the US carry at least one of the major three — Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon TCG, and Yu-Gi-Oh! — plus a rotating selection of whichever newer TCGs have local community traction (Disney Lorcana and One Piece TCG are the most commonly-added in 2026).
If you're planning a visit, call Highball Cincy directly to confirm current inventory. A 30-second call saves the trip if the shop doesn't carry what you're looking for. Ask specifically about:
- Sealed product: booster boxes, elite trainer boxes, starter decks, prerelease kits for the current set release window.
- Singles: individually-priced cards sold by set or by Standard/Commander archetype — the fastest way to finish a deck.
- Event schedule: weekly Friday Night Magic, Pokémon League, Yu-Gi-Oh! Locals, or whatever formats are currently running.
- Buylist / trade-in rates: whether the shop buys cards, in what condition, and at what percentage of market value for cash vs. store credit.
Local context
Highball Cincy has earned 117 Google reviews, a healthy number for a neighborhood LGS. Shops in this review band usually have a loyal core player base — the kind that shows up every Friday and knows which booster box release is coming next.
At 1834 Race St, the shop operates as a standalone independent — character-full spaces where the staff's taste shows through the inventory curation.
The shop maintains evening hours — advantageous for after-work players wanting to run 8pm Commander pods or late Friday Night Magic events without rushing from the office.
Plan a visit with confidence — the community vetting here is strong. Bring a deck, ask about upcoming events, and expect to leave having met at least one person you might play with again.
Frequently asked questions
Current hours are: Monday: Closed; Tuesday: Closed; Wednesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM; Thursday: 4:00 PM – 1:00 AM; Friday: 3:00 PM – 1:00 AM; Saturday: 1:00 PM – 1:00 AM; Sunday: 1:00 – 6:00 PM. Hours may change on holidays or around major TCG release weekends. We recommend calling ahead for same-day visits.
Yes — their website is https://www.highballcincy.com/. Most shop websites publish an event calendar, singles inventory search, and buylist rates. Check their site before visiting to confirm details.
Trading-card shops offer two payout paths: immediate cash or shop credit with a premium multiplier. Check Highball Cincy's current buylist pricing page (if published online) or ask during your visit — meta-staples fluctuate weekly, so timing matters on resale.
Some local shops partner with PSA, CGC, or BGS to bulk-submit grading on behalf of customers — the per-card fee is often lower than individual submissions. Confirm with Highball Cincy directly whether they currently accept grading intake.
Play space is foundational for an LGS — expect tables, sleeving supplies, and timer setups. Availability varies: Fridays and Saturdays are packed with tournament play; weekday mornings are quiet for casual pod games.
Family-friendliness is the norm at TCG stores. Pokémon League keeps the environment kid-appropriate, and Junior-division events separate younger competitors for fair matchups.
Parking in Cincinnati varies by neighborhood. Strip-mall locations usually include free adjacent lots; downtown and urban-core shops may require street parking or a paid garage. Refer to the map on this page for precise address and nearby options.
Nearby card shops in Ohio
Data about this shop is aggregated from public sources (Google Places, Wizards Play Network, Pokémon Play!, and our own verification). Hours, inventory, and event schedules can change; we recommend calling ahead before traveling. Shop owners: claim this listing to update information.